EmptyMessage board »Message Board home »Sign-in or register to get started
Online now: 0 members ; 9 anonymousDiscussion: Rule question
| Posted | Discussion |
| April 9 stattad Men's 65 235 posts | Rule question I looked in my rulebook and can't find anything that covers this. It happened in an ASA league game (I repeat, LEAGUE). Runners on 2nd and 3rd with 2 outs. Batter takes ball four and the ball bounces back to the backstop. The runner on 2nd forgot there was a runner on 3rd because he had a white shirt on instead of our blue. He takes off for 3rd, so the runner on 3rd takes off for the plate. The catcher picks up the ball and steps on the plate. The umpire called him out to end the inning. Is that the correct call? I thought the ball was dead in softball on a walk (unlike baseball). |
| April 9 Fred S Men's 85 297 posts | Rule question Rule 8.1.C.The ball is dead and runners may not advance unless forced. Ump has to go back to school. |
| April 9 cuda65 69 posts | Rule question I play ASA in McAllen, Texas and they allow stealing. In the situation just stated, the ball is alive and the runner on third can score. |
| April 10 Fred S Men's 85 297 posts | Rule question Right forgot that part. |
| April 11 Tommy00 13 posts | Rule question But, it is not a force out. The catcher would have to tag the runner coming home to make the third out. |
| April 11 OZ40 549 posts | Rule question Tommy In all the senior ball leagues I've seen and played in, if the catcher (or anyone else) tags a runner that has passed the commitment line between third and home he is ruled safe. In all plays at home the catcher or anyone wishing to put the runner out must have the ball in their possession and be in contact with the matt, if they tag the runner he is declared safe. |
| April 12 Tommy00 13 posts | Rule question OZ, I 100% agree with that, except for the fact that the OP said it was an ASA League game. :) |
| April 12 stattad Men's 65 235 posts | Rule question OZ is right. The catcher can never tag a runner at the plate. |
| April 12 stick8 1992 posts | Rule question Stattad, was this a senior league or regular mens league? I've never heard of a senior league that allows stealing. Did they have the second scoring plate and commit line? Many house leagues have their own rules regarding this and they do vary from town to town. If they allowed stealing in your league then the ump made the right call. If no stealing is allowed the ump should have sent the base runners back to 2nd and 3rd. |
